Mutual Insurance Agency, Inc.

Mutual Insurance Agency, Inc.

About Mutual Insurance Agency

Our Team

Pat McGlothin – Owner
Pat McGlothin - Owner, Mutual Insurance AgencyWith the agency since 1954, Pat has been serving customers in Tennessee for over 50 years. Born in Coalfield, Tennessee and a graduate of Central High School in Knoxville, Pat has a deep love for East Tennessee. After high school, Pat joined the military until he began playing minor league baseball. Pat moved on to play for the Brooklyn Dodgers during 1949/50.

Pat made his home in Knoxville where he and his wife Dorothy have two children, Steve and Suzan. He is a member of First Baptist Church, The Greater Knoxville Sports Hall of Fame and the MLB Players Association. He is also a 50 year Optimist Club Member, a 50 year Mason, and a community activist for the Boys and Girls Club. Pat enjoys exercising and watching baseball games.


Steve McGlothin – President
Steve McGlothin - President, Mutual Insurance AgencyWith the agency since 1972, Steve has over 35 years of experience in property and casualty insurance services. A graduate of Holston High School (67′) and The University of Tennessee (71′), he received his insurance license in 1972 after joining his father Pat at Mutual Insurance Agency.

Steve lives in Knoxville with his wife Carol and they have two sons, Patrick and Kevin.
He is a member of Cedar Springs Presbyterian Church, a 25 year member of the Kiwanis Club, and serves weekly meals at The Salvation Army. Steve enjoys playing golf and walking.


Kevin McGlothin – Vice President
Kevin McGlothin - Vice President, Mutual Insurance AgencyWith the agency since 2009, Kevin joined his family at Mutual Insurance Agency after graduating from The University of Tennessee with a Bachelor of Arts and then receiving his insurance license that same year.

Kevin lives in Knoxville with his wife, Jenny and their two dogs. He is a member of Sequoyah Hills Presbyterian Church and is an active volunteer with The Salvation Army.

Kevin enjoys tennis, golf and University of Tennessee athletics.


Melissa Rhinehart – Office Manager
Melissa Rhinehart - Office Manager, Mutual Insurance AgencyThe first person you see when you walk through the door, Melissa has been with Mutual Insurance Agency for 27 years. She received her insurance license in 1998 and is the head liaison with our insurance providers, specializing in matching our customers insurance needs with competitive rates.

Melissa lives in Knoxville with her husband Randy and has one son, Derrick. She enjoys cooking and being with her cats.


Suzan DeWine – Customer Service Representative
Suzan DeWine - Customer Service Representative, Mutual Insurance AgencyJoining her father and brother at Mutual Insurance Agency in 1985, Suzan has been taking great care of customers with exceptional service and attention to detail for over 25 years. Suzan lives in Knoxville and has two daughters, Kristin and Kim. She enjoys walking, swimming and traveling.